EFF to Court: Strike Down Age Estimation in California But Not Consumer Privacy

The Electronic Frontier Foundation called on the Ninth Circuit to rule that California's Age Appropriate Design Code violates the First Amendment, while not casting doubt on well-written data privacy laws.
EFF filed an amicus brief in the case NetChoice v. Bonta, along with the Center for Democracy & Technology.
A lower court already ruled the law is likely unconstitutional.
EFF agrees, but we asked the appeals court to chart a narrower path.
The lower court also incorrectly suggested that many foundational consumer privacy principles cannot pass First Amendment scrutiny.
That is a mistake that EFF asked the Ninth Circuit to fix.
In late 2022, California passed the AADC with the goal of protecting children online.
It has many data privacy provisions that EFF would like to see in a comprehensive federal privacy bill, like data minimization, strong limits on the processing of geolocation data, regulation of dark patterns, and enforcement of privacy policies.
Government should provide such privacy protections to all people.
The protections in the AADC are only guaranteed to children.
While the method is not specified, techniques could include submitting a government ID or a biometric scan of your face.
In its brief, EFF argued that the AADC's age estimation scheme raises the same problems as other age verification laws that have been almost universally struck down, often with help from EFF. The AADC burdens adults' and children's access to protected speech and frustrates all users' right to speak anonymously online.
EFF argued that the vague terms offer no clear standards, and thus give government officials too much discretion in deciding what conduct is forbidden, while incentivizing platforms to self-censor given uncertainty about what is allowed.
Because age estimation is essential to the AADC, the entire law should be struck down for that reason alone, without assessing the privacy provisions.
If the court instead chooses to address the AADC's privacy protections, EFF cautioned that many of the principles reflected in those provisions, when stripped of the unconstitutional censorship provisions and vague terms, could survive intermediate scrutiny.
EFF has a long history of supporting well-written privacy laws against First Amendment attacks.
We have filed briefs supporting laws that protect video viewing history, biometric data, and other internet records.
We have advocated for a federal law to protect reproductive health records.
We have written extensively on the need for a strong federal privacy law.


This Cyber News was published on www.eff.org. Publication date: Thu, 15 Feb 2024 00:13:04 +0000


Cyber News related to EFF to Court: Strike Down Age Estimation in California But Not Consumer Privacy

EFF to Court: Strike Down Age Estimation in California But Not Consumer Privacy - The Electronic Frontier Foundation called on the Ninth Circuit to rule that California's Age Appropriate Design Code violates the First Amendment, while not casting doubt on well-written data privacy laws. EFF filed an amicus brief in the case ...
8 months ago Eff.org
Fighting For Your Digital Rights Across the Country: Year in Review 2023 - EFF works every year to improve policy in ways that protect your digital rights in states across the country. Thanks to the messages of hundreds of EFF members across the country, we've spoken up for digital rights this year from Sacramento to ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Privacy Isn't Dead. Far From It. - EFF is one of dozens, if not hundreds, of organizations that work to protect privacy. Millions of people read EFF's website each year, and tens of millions use the tools we've made, like Privacy Badger. Privacy is one of EFF's biggest concerns, and ...
8 months ago Eff.org
2023 Year in Review: The U.S. Supreme Court's Busy Year of Free Speech and Tech Cases - The U.S. Supreme Court has taken an unusually active interest in internet free speech issues. EFF participated as amicus in a whopping nine cases before the court this year. The court decided four of those cases, and decisions in the remaining five ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Privacy Education for Students: A Vital Curriculum Component - Recognizing privacy as a fundamental right, educators are increasingly acknowledging the importance of integrating privacy education into the curriculum. This article explores the significance of privacy education for students and its role as a vital ...
10 months ago Securityzap.com
It's Time For Lawmakers to Listen to Courts: Your Law Regulating Online Speech Will Harm Internet Users' Free Speech Rights - Despite a long history of courts ruling that government efforts to regulate speech online harm all internet users and interfere with their First Amendment rights, state and federal lawmakers continue to pass laws that do just that. Three separate ...
4 months ago Eff.org
EFF Continues Fight Against Unconstitutional Geofence and Keyword Search Warrants: 2023 Year in Review - EFF continues to fight back against high-tech general warrants that compel companies to search broad swaths of users' personal data. In 2023, we saw victory and setbacks in a pair of criminal cases that challenged the constitutionality of geofence ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Mississippi Can't Wall Off Everyone's Social Media Access to Protect Children - In what is becoming a recurring theme, Mississippi became the latest state to pass a law requiring social media services to verify users' ages and block lawful speech to young people. Once again, EFF explained to the court why the law is ...
4 months ago Eff.org
EFF Asks Court to Uphold Federal Law That Protects Online Video Viewers' Privacy and Free Expression - As millions of internet users watch videos online for news and entertainment, it is essential to uphold a federal privacy law that protects against the disclosure of everyone's viewing history, EFF argued in court last month. For decades, the Video ...
10 months ago Eff.org
First, Let's Talk About Consumer Privacy: 2023 Year in Review - Whatever online harms you want to alleviate on the internet today, you can do it better-with a broader impact-if you enact strong consumer data privacy legislation first. That is a grounding principle that has informed much of EFF's consumer ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Hackers breach Australian court hearing database - The court system for Australia's second-most-populated state was hit by a ransomware attack that potentially exposed sensitive recordings of some court hearings. Court Services Victoria, an administrative body that supports the operations of the ...
10 months ago Therecord.media
One Day in the Life of EFF's Activism Team - EFF's activism team includes experienced issue experts, master communicators, and grassroots organizers who help to coordinate and orchestrate EFF's activist campaigns that include but go well beyond litigation, technical analyses and solutions, and ...
5 months ago Eff.org
Business Data Privacy Laws: Compliance and Beyond - Governments worldwide have implemented strict data privacy laws to protect individuals' information in the face of increasing cyber threats and data breaches. Let's dive into the world of business data privacy laws as we navigate the complexities of ...
9 months ago Securityzap.com
Victory! Grand Jury Finds Sacramento Cops Illegally Shared Driver Data - For the past year, EFF has been sounding the alarm about police in California illegally sharing drivers' location data with anti-abortion states, putting abortion seekers and providers at risk of prosecution. We thus applaud the Sacramento County ...
4 months ago Eff.org
EFF Membership: 2023 Year In Review - Throughout the many years that EFF has been around, our goal has remained consistent: creating a future where you have your rights when you go online, and one where they are enhanced by new technologies. Our goal isn't the only part of EFF that has ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Victory! Montana's Unprecedented TikTok Ban is Unconstitutional - A federal court on Thursday blocked Montana's effort to ban TikTok from the state, ruling that the law violated users' First Amendment rights to speak and to access information online, and the company's First Amendment rights to select and curate ...
11 months ago Eff.org
My Yearly Look Back, a Look Forward and a Warning - 2023 saw cybersecurity and privacy law arrive at a crossroads, especially with regard to the regulatory landscape. This is the time of year when it is traditional to look back at the past year and extrapolate forward to make predictions for the year ...
9 months ago Securityboulevard.com
Holistic Approach To Privacy and Security in Tech - In this article, I would like to explain how I tackle privacy and security issues that are specific for large scale web and mobile applications and Big Tech. First, let's outline some of the biggest challenges Big Tech companies deal with in terms of ...
10 months ago Feeds.dzone.com
Thought GDPR Compliance Was Hard? Buckle Up - COMMENTARY. Five years since the European Union's General Data Protection Regulation took effect, its fingerprints are everywhere: from proliferating privacy laws worldwide to the now-ubiquitous consent banners seen across websites of every kind. For ...
11 months ago Darkreading.com
Protecting Student Privacy Online - In the rapidly evolving world of online education, the protection of student privacy has emerged as a critical concern. This article delves into the privacy risks associated with online education and highlights the significance of complying with ...
10 months ago Securityzap.com
Ofcom publishes UK age verification proposals The Register - The UK's communications regulator has laid out guidance on how online services might perform age checks as part of the Online Safety Act. The range of proposals from Ofcom are likely to send privacy activists running for the hills. These include ...
11 months ago Go.theregister.com
Dozens of Rogue California Police Agencies Still Sharing Driver Locations with Anti-Abortion States - SAN FRANCISCO-California Attorney General Rob Bonta should crack down on police agencies that still violate Californians' privacy by sharing automated license plate reader information with out-of-state government agencies, putting abortion seekers ...
9 months ago Eff.org
EFF Helps News Organizations Push Back Against Legal Bullying from Cyber Mercenary Group - For the last several months, there has emerged a campaign of bullying and censorship seeking to wipe out stories about the mercenary hacking campaigns of a less well-known company, Appin Technology, in general, and the company's cofounder, Rajat ...
8 months ago Eff.org
Victory! Police Drone Footage is Not Categorically Exempt From California's Public Records Law - Video footage captured by police drones sent in response to 911 calls cannot be kept entirely secret from the public, a California appellate court ruled last week. The police department is the first law enforcement agency in the country to use drones ...
10 months ago Eff.org
EFF to Court: Electronic Ankle Monitoring Is Bad. Sharing That Data Is Even Worse. - The government violates the privacy rights of individuals on pretrial release when it continuously tracks, retains, and shares their location, EFF explained in a friend-of-the-court brief filed in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. In the case, ...
5 months ago Eff.org

Latest Cyber News


Cyber Trends (last 7 days)


Trending Cyber News (last 7 days)