EFF Reminds the Supreme Court That Copyright Trolls Are Still a Problem

At EFF, we spend a lot of time calling out the harm caused by copyright trolls and protecting internet users from their abuses.
Copyright trolls are serial plaintiffs who use search tools to identify technical, often low-value infringements on the internet, and then seek nuisance settlements from many defendants.
These trolls take advantage of some of copyright law's worst features-especially the threat of massive, unpredictable statutory damages-to impose a troublesome tax on many uses of the internet.
On Monday, EFF continued the fight against copyright trolls by filing an amicus brief in Warner Chappell Music v. Nealy, a case pending in the U.S. Supreme Court.
The case doesn't deal with copyright trolls directly.
Rather, it involves the interpretation of the statute of limitations in copyright cases.
Statutes of limitations are laws that limit the time after an event within which legal proceedings may be initiated.
The purpose is to encourage plaintiffs to file their claims promptly, and to avoid stale claims and unfairness to defendants when time has passed and evidence might be lost.
In California, the statute of limitations for a breach of contract claim is generally four years.
Warner Chappell Music, the defendant in the case, argued that the claim accrued when the alleged infringement occurred, giving a plaintiff three years after that to recover damages.
All they have to do is argue that they couldn't reasonably have discovered the infringement until recently.
The trolls' targets would have trouble defending against ancient claims, and be more likely to have to pay nuisance settlements.
EFF's amicus brief provided the court with an overview of the copyright trolling problem and gave examples of types of trolls.
The brief then showed how an unlimited look-back period for damages under the discovery rule adds risk and uncertainty for the targets of copyright trolls and would encourage abuse of the legal system.
EFF's brief in this case is a little unusual-the case doesn't directly involve technology or technology companies.
The party we're supporting is a leading music publishing company.
Because statutes of limitations are fundamental to the justice system, this infrequent coalition perhaps isn't that surprising.
In many previous copyright troll cases, the courts have caught on to their abuse of the judicial system, and taken steps to shut down the trolling.
EFF filed its brief in this case to ask the Supreme Court to extend these judicial safeguards, by holding that copyright infringement damages can only be recovered for acts occurring three years before the filing of the complaint.
An indefinite statute of limitations would throw gasoline on the patent troll fire and risk encouraging new trolls to come out from under the figurative bridge.


This Cyber News was published on www.eff.org. Publication date: Thu, 07 Dec 2023 19:43:09 +0000


Cyber News related to EFF Reminds the Supreme Court That Copyright Trolls Are Still a Problem

EFF Reminds the Supreme Court That Copyright Trolls Are Still a Problem - At EFF, we spend a lot of time calling out the harm caused by copyright trolls and protecting internet users from their abuses. Copyright trolls are serial plaintiffs who use search tools to identify technical, often low-value infringements on the ...
11 months ago Eff.org
It's Copyright Week 2024: Join Us in the Fight for Better Copyright Law and Policy - We're taking part in Copyright Week, a series of actions and discussions supporting key principles that should guide copyright policy. Every day this week, various groups are taking on different elements of copyright law and policy, addressing what's ...
9 months ago Eff.org
2023 Year in Review: The U.S. Supreme Court's Busy Year of Free Speech and Tech Cases - The U.S. Supreme Court has taken an unusually active interest in internet free speech issues. EFF participated as amicus in a whopping nine cases before the court this year. The court decided four of those cases, and decisions in the remaining five ...
10 months ago Eff.org
EFF Continues Fight Against Unconstitutional Geofence and Keyword Search Warrants: 2023 Year in Review - EFF continues to fight back against high-tech general warrants that compel companies to search broad swaths of users' personal data. In 2023, we saw victory and setbacks in a pair of criminal cases that challenged the constitutionality of geofence ...
10 months ago Eff.org
EFF to Ninth Circuit: There's No Software Exception to Traditional Copyright Limits - Copyright's reach is already far too broad, and courts have no business expanding it any further, particularly where that reframing will undermine adversarial interoperability. If a work is derivative, it may infringe the copyright in the preexisting ...
7 months ago Eff.org
Victory: Utah Supreme Court Upholds Right to Refuse to Tell Cops Your Passcode - Last week, the Utah Supreme Court ruled that prosecutors violated a defendant's Fifth Amendment privilege against self incrimination when they presented testimony about his refusal to give police the passcode to his cell phone. This closely tracks ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Congress Must Stop Pushing Bills That Will Benefit Patent Trolls - The U.S. Senate is moving forward with two bills that would enrich patent trolls, patent system insiders, and a few large companies that rely on flimsy patents, at the expense of everyone else. One bill, the Patent Eligibility Restoration Act would ...
7 months ago Eff.org
It's Time For Lawmakers to Listen to Courts: Your Law Regulating Online Speech Will Harm Internet Users' Free Speech Rights - Despite a long history of courts ruling that government efforts to regulate speech online harm all internet users and interfere with their First Amendment rights, state and federal lawmakers continue to pass laws that do just that. Three separate ...
4 months ago Eff.org
EFF Urges Supreme Court to Set Standard for How Government Can and Can't Talk to Social Media Sites About Censoring Users' Posts - WASHINGTON, DC-The Supreme Court should clarify standards for determining if the government permissibly advised or convinced social media companies to censor content from 2020 to 2022, or impermissibly coerced or threatened sites in violation of the ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Hackers breach Australian court hearing database - The court system for Australia's second-most-populated state was hit by a ransomware attack that potentially exposed sensitive recordings of some court hearings. Court Services Victoria, an administrative body that supports the operations of the ...
10 months ago Therecord.media
EFF to Court: Strike Down Age Estimation in California But Not Consumer Privacy - The Electronic Frontier Foundation called on the Ninth Circuit to rule that California's Age Appropriate Design Code violates the First Amendment, while not casting doubt on well-written data privacy laws. EFF filed an amicus brief in the case ...
8 months ago Eff.org
EFF Membership: 2023 Year In Review - Throughout the many years that EFF has been around, our goal has remained consistent: creating a future where you have your rights when you go online, and one where they are enhanced by new technologies. Our goal isn't the only part of EFF that has ...
10 months ago Eff.org
One Day in the Life of EFF's Activism Team - EFF's activism team includes experienced issue experts, master communicators, and grassroots organizers who help to coordinate and orchestrate EFF's activist campaigns that include but go well beyond litigation, technical analyses and solutions, and ...
5 months ago Eff.org
How To Fight Bad Patents: 2023 Year In Review - EFF's longstanding project of fighting for a more balanced, just patent system has always borne free expression in mind. Patent trolls, who simply use intellectual property rights to extract money from others, continue to be a barrier to people who ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Records of Crucial Cases May Have Been Compromised by a Cyberattack on Victoria's Court System - An independent expert believes that ransomware was used to assault Victoria's court system and that the attack was coordinated by Russian hackers. According to a representative for Court Services Victoria, hackers gained access to a portion of the ...
10 months ago Cysecurity.news
Fighting For Your Digital Rights Across the Country: Year in Review 2023 - EFF works every year to improve policy in ways that protect your digital rights in states across the country. Thanks to the messages of hundreds of EFF members across the country, we've spoken up for digital rights this year from Sacramento to ...
10 months ago Eff.org
SXSW Tried to Silence Critics with Bogus Trademark and Copyright Claims. EFF Fought Back. - Special thanks to EFF legal intern Jack Beck, who was the lead author of this post. Amid heavy criticism for its ties to weapons manufacturers supplying Israel, South by Southwest-the organizer of an annual conference and music festival in Austin-has ...
7 months ago Eff.org
EFF Helps News Organizations Push Back Against Legal Bullying from Cyber Mercenary Group - For the last several months, there has emerged a campaign of bullying and censorship seeking to wipe out stories about the mercenary hacking campaigns of a less well-known company, Appin Technology, in general, and the company's cofounder, Rajat ...
8 months ago Eff.org
Victory! Montana's Unprecedented TikTok Ban is Unconstitutional - A federal court on Thursday blocked Montana's effort to ban TikTok from the state, ruling that the law violated users' First Amendment rights to speak and to access information online, and the company's First Amendment rights to select and curate ...
11 months ago Eff.org
Victoria court recordings exposed in reported ransomware attack - Australia's Court Services Victoria is warning that video recordings of court hearings were exposed after suffering a reported Qilin ransomware attack. CSV is an independent statutory authority that provides services to Victoria's court systems, ...
10 months ago Bleepingcomputer.com
EFF Asks Court to Uphold Federal Law That Protects Online Video Viewers' Privacy and Free Expression - As millions of internet users watch videos online for news and entertainment, it is essential to uphold a federal privacy law that protects against the disclosure of everyone's viewing history, EFF argued in court last month. For decades, the Video ...
10 months ago Eff.org
Supreme Court Backs Biden Social Media - US Supreme Court sides with Biden after Republican-led states challenged federal halt of misinformation posts on social media. The Supreme Court on Wednesday sided with the Biden administration in a dispute with Republican-led US states over how far ...
4 months ago Silicon.co.uk
Making the Law Accessible in Europe and the USA - Earlier this month, the European Union Court of Justice ruled that harmonized standards are a part of EU law, and thus must be accessible to EU citizens and residents free of charge. While it might seem like common sense that the laws that govern us ...
7 months ago Eff.org
More Than a Decade Later, Site-Blocking Is Still Censorship - We're taking part in Copyright Week, a series of actions and discussions supporting key principles that should guide copyright policy. Every day this week, various groups are taking on different elements of copyright law and policy, addressing what's ...
9 months ago Eff.org
The Alaska Supreme Court Takes Aerial Surveillance's Threat to Privacy Seriously, Other Courts Should Too - In March, the Alaska Supreme Court held in State v. McKelvey that the Alaska Constitution required law enforcement to obtain a warrant before photographing a private backyard from an aircraft. In this case, the police took photographs of Mr. ...
5 months ago Eff.org

Latest Cyber News


Cyber Trends (last 7 days)


Trending Cyber News (last 7 days)